McDermott vs. Meucci: Which Pool Cue is Right for You?

McDermott vs. Meucci: Which Pool Cue is Right for You?

McDermott vs. Meucci:
Which Pool Cue is Right for You?

by Julia Patrick | February 14, 2020

Choosing the right pool cue can significantly impact your game, and with so many options available, it can be challenging to determine which brand to trust. Two of the most reputable names in the industry are McDermott and Meucci. While both brands offer high-quality cues, we believe McDermott stands out for several reasons. Let's delve into a detailed comparison to help you decide which pool cue is right for you.

Craftsmanship and Quality

McDermott

  • Superior Craftsmanship: McDermott cues are renowned for their exceptional craftsmanship. Each cue is meticulously crafted using premium materials, including exotic woods and high-quality inlays. The attention to detail in McDermott cues is evident in their flawless finish and intricate designs.
  • Durability: McDermott cues are built to last. The brand's commitment to quality ensures that each cue is not only beautiful but also durable, capable of withstanding the rigors of regular play.
  • UV Finish: Unlike Meucci, McDermott uses an expensive UV finish that maintains its clarity over time, preventing yellowing and providing superior protection against dents and scratches.
  • Urethane Plastic: McDermott uses high-quality urethane plastic, known for its exceptional impact resistance, flexibility, and abrasion resistance. This material is more durable and stronger than PVC, which Meucci often uses under the guise of terms like "high impact plastic" or "power piston."
  • Lifetime Warranty: McDermott stands behind their products with a lifetime warranty that covers manufacturing defects, a testament to their confidence in the durability and quality of their cues.

Meucci

  • Inconsistent Craftsmanship: Meucci cues, while offering attractive designs, have been reported to use lacquer finishes that yellow quickly and are more susceptible to dents and damage. This can impact both the aesthetic and functional longevity of the cue.

  • Material Substitution: Meucci has been known to start with exotic woods and later substitute them with less expensive types, potentially affecting the cue's performance and durability.
  • Use of PVC: Meucci markets their plastic components as "high impact plastic" or with terms like "power piston," but these components are actually made from standard PVC, which does not offer the same durability as the urethane plastic used by McDermott.
  • Linen Wrap Issues: Meucci lacquers over their linen wraps, which frequently develop cracks. These cracks are not covered by Meucci's warranty, leading to potential aesthetic and performance issues.
  • Limited Warranty: Meucci's warranty only covers defects that affect performance and is limited to one year. Additionally, it does not cover aesthetic issues, which can be a significant concern given the reported tendency of their finishes to yellow and wear.

Performance

McDermott

  • Consistency: McDermott cues are known for their consistent performance. The cues are well-balanced, offering a perfect blend of power and control, which is essential for both amateur and professional players.
  • Customizability: McDermott cues can be customized to fit individual player preferences, including weight, shaft diameter, and wrap type. This flexibility ensures that players can find a cue that suits their playing style perfectly.

Meucci

  • Performance: Meucci cues are designed to provide good performance, particularly with their low-deflection shafts. However, the use of lower-quality materials and issues with the linen wrap can affect the overall feel and longevity of the cue.

Aesthetics

McDermott

  • Visual Appeal: McDermott cues are known for their stunning designs and intricate inlays. The brand offers a wide range of aesthetically pleasing cues that are sure to catch the eye of any player.
  • Variety: With a vast selection of designs, McDermott ensures that there is a cue for every taste, whether you prefer a classic look or something more modern and flashy.

Meucci

  • Designs: Meucci cues also feature attractive designs with intricate inlays. However, the yellowing lacquer and potential material substitutions can detract from their long-term visual appeal.

Value for Money

McDermott

  • Investment: McDermott cues are an excellent investment for players looking for a high-quality, durable, and visually appealing cue. The lifetime warranty adds significant value, providing peace of mind for the long term.
  • Resale Value: McDermott cues tend to hold their value well, making them a smart choice for players who may consider selling or upgrading their cue in the future.

Cost Comparison

Meucci Pool Cues

Meucci pool cues are known for their intricate designs and performance shafts, but they have become more expensive in recent years. Here are some typical prices for Meucci cues:

  • BMC Casino Series: Prices range from approximately $1,160 to $1,495, depending on the specific model and customization options available.
  • 21st Century Series: These cues are typically priced around $1,200.
  • Economy and Special Editions: Some models like the Economy Cure are available for about $600, while other special editions can go up to $1,495.

McDermott Pool Cues

McDermott cues are also high-quality and feature extensive customization options. Here's a look at some recent prices for McDermott cues:

  • G Series: Mid-range McDermott cues like the G701 with I-2 shaft can be found around $500 to $800, offering great value for money with excellent craftsmanship and durability.
  • Higher-End Models: More intricate designs and advanced models can cost upwards of $1,000, but they generally remain competitive compared to similar Meucci models.

Conclusion

While both McDermott and Meucci are respected brands in the pool cue industry, McDermott cues have the edge when it comes to craftsmanship, durability, and overall value. The lifetime warranty, superior consistency, and wide range of customization options make McDermott cues a standout choice for players at all levels. Meucci cues, on the other hand, have been noted for their use of lower-quality materials, less durable finishes, and issues with their linen wraps, which may impact their long-term value and performance.

If you’re looking for a cue that combines top-notch performance with stunning aesthetics and long-term reliability, McDermott is the brand to choose. Explore our selection of McDermott cues today and elevate your game to the next level!

Explore McDermott Pool Cues | Explore Meucci Pool Cues